IDKMOS vs ILTY in Classic Whitney Archive II Forum

RSS
Email

0 Points

IDKMOS vs ILTY

Author	Comment
.	IDKMOS vs ILTY	Lead	[-]
Diamond Posts: 5524 Jul 24 09 11:03 AM Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	Tags : None I have to say that in my opinion Whitney sounds stronger on IDKMOS, it's as if she's singing more powerful and less calculated... Just compare both bridges for example... I also think IDKMOS would make a better single, it has more punch to it, and of course it can be remixed... However, ILTY is definitely sung with more feeling and emotion, and it has more beautiful notes especially the head voice (falsetto) notes, however it feels more like a gospel song so I think it's less commercial than IDKMOS... ILTY is very spiritual... I love both songs equally, but for different reasons... how would you compare both?
papersamus		#1	[-]
New Release Posts: 60 Jul 24 09 11:05 AM Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	ILTY wins for me. It speaks more to my heart and her voice is a lot more smooth. The first few lines always get to me!
LoverForLife04		#2	[-]
Diamond Posts: 7718 Jul 24 09 11:07 AM Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	To me, ILTY sounds closer to the way we used to hear Whitney, it could have been on the soundtrack to The Preacher's Wife and blended in pretty well. Where as IDKMOS vocally sounds more akin to Just Whitney (BUT MUCH BETTER) lol. I love both songs! They are both powerful, I would say that IDKMOS sounds a bit more personal and powerful for Whitney. I think for the general audience and the reactions to both songs, I would say that ILTY give a better overall vocal presentation.
FilmmakerLA		#3	[-]
Diamond Posts: 8689 Jul 24 09 11:08 AM Gold Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	ILTY. Hands down. Not even a contest.
ThroughWithLove		#4	[-]
Platinum Posts: 1994 Jul 24 09 11:08 AM Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	Personally, i think IDKMOS's lyrics would keep it from being a big hit. On other music forums i use, when IDKMOS was leaked, the reaction was split: people loved it or hated it, yet both sides hated the lyrics. Yet when i posted ILTY on these forums last night, everyone loved her voice and the lyrics of it much more and there was not one person who hated it on those boards
Tetotal		#5	[-]
Platinum Posts: 1095 Jul 24 09 11:09 AM Bronze Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	ILTY hands down!
rainshower1		#6	[-]
Diamond Posts: 5769 Jul 24 09 11:12 AM Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	I Look To You, in every single way!!!!!!! No question. I listened to original IDKMOS all the way through 2 times. Then I listened to one of the remixes about 10 times. I am already at 50 on this song.
Whitfan87		#7	[-]
Gold Posts: 598 Jul 24 09 11:12 AM Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	I Look To You
proudwhitneyfan		#8	[-]
Platinum Posts: 1829 Jul 24 09 11:13 AM Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	I like IDKMOS better.....it's more powerful and when I first heard it, it gave me chills...... I love ILTY as well....her voice is smooth.....but I still have to go with IDKMOS
savannah86		#9	[-]
Diamond Posts: 2605 Jul 24 09 11:16 AM Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	ILTY
Mariah10Carey88		#10	[-]
New Release Posts: 30 Jul 24 09 11:17 AM Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	I like the melody of IDKMOS better, but I prefer her vocals on ILTY.
DXL226		#11	[-]
Gold Posts: 753 Jul 24 09 11:19 AM Gold Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	IMO Lyrics and production are better on I Look To You I like the vocals better on I Didn't Know My Own Strength, there is a little more power in it than ILTY.
Avar20		#12	[-]
Platinum Posts: 1865 Jul 24 09 11:21 AM Gold Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	ILTY clear winner for me..Not even close
Special Kev		#13	[-]
Diamond Posts: 13852 Jul 24 09 11:21 AM Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	Definitely ILTY!
JoeyOnTheRun		#14	[-]
Diamond Posts: 4885 Jul 24 09 11:22 AM Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	ILTY is a better song
tonythetiger1		#15	[-]
Diamond Posts: 5791 Jul 24 09 11:23 AM Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	ILTY hands down.
simbadiva		#16	[-]
Gold Posts: 543 Jul 24 09 11:24 AM Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	Vocally ILTY is classic Whitney, but it's lacking a couple of high notes at the end to make it perfection. IDKMOS is too strained but it does showcase her power with that huuuge "Crumble" at the end. ILTY overall is easily better!
jasmineuk28		#17	[-]
Platinum Posts: 1295 Jul 24 09 11:25 AM Gold Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	Its a tough one for me. I love both songs. I Look To You - I feel Whitneys voice carries this song completely. The song is beautiful but im going to be honest, I think the production sucks. Its not big enough. The drums are weak and its not Whitneys voice that doesnt go anywhere, its the production. Verdict Vocals - excellent Song - excellent Production - poor I didnt know my own strength - Well, Ive only heard the leaked version so i cant judge it properly. I love the song and I love the production, Whitneys voice is good but a bit raw in parts but it does add to the feel. Verdict Vocals - good Song - excellent Production - good So I Look To You has the edge for me but i cant help but being more dissapointed with it than strength cos it has the potential to be an amazing power ballad but the production lets it down for me.
Brasil20		#18	[-]
Diamond Posts: 2843 Jul 24 09 11:25 AM Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	people can relate more to "I look to you" 's lyrics, the melody is easier to remember and when it comes to delivered emotion there's not even a contest, ILTY wins easily
BobbyMello		#19	[-]
Registered User Posts: 0 Jul 24 09 11:30 AM Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	ILTY is much better tha IDKMOS in all aspects!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Favor1219		#20	[-]
Gold Posts: 602 Jul 24 09 11:30 AM Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	"I Look To You", by mountains! This song is better than IDKMOS in EVERY way to me. Vocally, lyrically, production, etc. I knew it from the 30 sec. snippet. IDKMOS did absolutely nothing for me, ILTY is emotional. I can hear this song in church - this is a worship song.

<< Previous Topic Next Topic >>

Yuku free message boards

IDKMOS vs ILTY

IDKMOS vs ILTY